The original Puffed Wheat Square: A 100-year-old Red Deer treat

Much like Nanaimo bars and butter tarts, puffed wheat squares are Canadian treasure, but did you know that they were invented in Red Deer? In 1913, maritimer Alfred James Russell settled in Red Deer and opened a candy store. The store was located on Red Deer’s Ross St., not far from where The Hub now sits. A.J. Russell sold popular local treats such as all-day suckers, coconut “ping-pong” brittle, and the ever famous puffed wheat square.

With that start of World War I in 1914, Canadians were advised to find substitutes to using wheat in their everyday cooking and baking. With a large majority of Canadian and American wheat crops shipped to troops overseas, many bakers and confectionaries were left with the task of replacing once common ingredients with similar alternatives. The use of puffed grains, such as rice and wheat, became increasingly popular because it took less product to make more.

A.J. Russell’s original puffed wheat square used molasses, a common WWI alternative to sugar, but over the years chocolate and marshmallows have become a popular substitute. However, with the help of the Red Deer & District Archives, we have been able to track down A.J. Russell’s original puffed wheat square recipe.

See Recipe Below

Read More Red Deer Fun

Original Puffed Wheat Candy Recipe

What You Will Need

  • 2 cups of white sugar
  • 1/2 cup of corn syrup
  • 1/2 cup of water
  • 1/8 lb. (1/4 cup) of butter
  • 2 tbsp. of vanilla
  • 1/4 tsp. of salt
  • 4 cups of puffed wheat
  • A large pot
  • Thermometer
  • An oiled flat surface, like a cutting board or cooking tray

Directions

1. Preheat your a large pot on stovetop to 250°
2. Add water, corn syrup, and white sugar to pot while stirring
3. Put thermometer into pot and bring to a boil at 280° without stirring
4. Add the butter, vanilla, and salt while stirring slowly
5. Bring temperature up to 280° again
6. Add puffed wheat and mix thoroughly into candy mixture
7. Empty pot of puffed wheat concoction on the oiled surface, continually stretching while mixture hardens

Tips and Tricks for Bakers

The biggest challenge when making puffed wheat squares is making them gooey and soft enough that they stay fresh and easy to eat, but not so soft that they fall apart in your hands. Here are a couple tips and tricks to get your squares just right:

  • Cooking time is important! Don’t let your mixture boil too long or the moisture will escape and make your squares hard and dense.
  • Not sure how to test if your candy mixture is done? Drop a small dollop of the mixture into a cup of cold water. If it forms a ball, you’re good.
  • Press the squares into a buttered pan, with wet or buttered hands, so they will maintain their shape while not sticking to you.

Molasses: The Ultimate Question

Modern puffed wheat squares are much softer and gooier than A.J. Russell’s original recipe, most likely due to our modern ingredients and baking methods. A.J. Russell’s recipe is very traditional hard candy with puffed wheat mixed in, rather than the Rice Krispie-like square we see today. You’ll find lots of tips and tricks, like melt ten large marshmallows into the mixture to make it extra gooey or add a couple of tablespoons of peanut butter for extra flavour.

With sugar rationing during WWI and WWII, molasses became a popular baking ingredient as a sweetener substitute. With sugar now widely available, molasses is often not used to make modern puffed wheat squares. Instead, many different ingredients such as marshmallows are now used. Cocoa powder is another popular ingredient you see in modern recipes, as it replicates the dark brown colour of molasses originally gave the squares but adds another hint of flavour.